Reviews

The Lord Of The Rings: The War Of Rohirrim (12A) |Close-Up Film Review

Dir: Kenji Kamiyama, US/New Zealand/Japan  2024, 134mins

Cast: Brain Cox, Gaia Wise, Miranda Otto

Review by Matthew Morlai Kamara

It’s not widely known that an animated Lord of the Rings film was released in 1978, later finding a home on VHS during the 80s. Now, 46 years later, another animated installment arrives—this time as part of Peter Jackson’s celebrated Lord of the Rings franchise.

The War of the Rohirrim, directed by Kenji Kamiyama and produced with Jackson’s guidance, intentionally draws from the visual style of the 1978 classic. The CGI may seem simplistic by today’s standards, but this feels like a conscious nod to its predecessor, reviving the charm of an era when animation was raw and imaginative. Jackson subtly incorporates modern enhancements, much like applying a fine glaze to a vintage artwork, ensuring it resonates with contemporary audiences while honoring its roots.

The voice cast delivers outstanding performances, imbuing the characters with genuine emotion. Yet, the film stumbles during its more dialogue-driven moments, where the pacing slows considerably. These scenes mirror some of the slower stretches in Jackson’s live-action trilogy but lack the same gripping intensity. Fortunately, the battle sequences bring the energy back, offering thrilling and visually striking moments that deliver on the epic scale fans expect from Middle Earth.

As a producer, Jackson’s influence is unmistakable, and his commitment to Tolkien’s world shines through. While it doesn’t quite match the heights of his live-action masterpieces, The War of the Rohirrim succeeds as a meaningful and heartfelt addition to the franchise. It captures the essence of Tolkien’s universe while paying homage to the animated adaptation that paved the way.

Despite some shortcomings, this film serves as a tribute to fans, blending nostalgia with a forward-looking vision. It’s a worthy continuation that keeps the magic of Middle Earth alive, connecting the past and present in a way that feels both celebratory and respectful.